No swamp in my backyard: legal challenges to wetland restoration projects in Flanders (Belgium)—a case law analysis
Schoukens, H.; van der Burgt, N. (2026). No swamp in my backyard: legal challenges to wetland restoration projects in Flanders (Belgium)—a case law analysis. Restor. Ecol. 34(S1): e70245. https://dx.doi.org/10.1111/rec.70245
In: Restoration Ecology. Blackwell: Cambridge, Mass.. ISSN 1061-2971; e-ISSN 1526-100X, more
|  |
| Keyword |
Water bodies > Inland waters > Wetlands
|
| Author keywords |
ecosystem restoration, legal obstacles, nature restoration law, nuisance, property law |
| Authors | | Top |
- Schoukens, H., more
- van der Burgt, N.
|
|
|
| Abstract |
With the adoption of the EU Nature Restoration Law in June 2024, EU Member States will have to upscale their wetland restoration actions in the coming years. However, increasingly large-scale wetland restoration projects face challenges in national courts because of stakeholder opposition, revealing a multitude of legal barriers that might arise. This paper examines recent court cases launched against wetland restoration projects in Flanders, a region in Belgium once characterized by vast wetlands and marshes. The conclusion shows that no legal action against wetland restoration projects has succeeded, since judges tend to back the ecosystem services wetlands offer, including flood protection and biodiversity conservation. The case law examined demonstrates that public benefit takes precedence over personal issues like fears of more mosquitoes or property-related concerns. According to case law, comprehensive and precise Environmental Impact Assessments that pinpoint and analyze all potential negative impacts of wetland restoration programs are essential for large-scale wetland restoration projects and to defend them legally. In summary, the case law analysis shows that wetlands are viewed more favorably now, unlike past negative cultural views. |
|
